Pope Leo XIV Says Machine-Made Images Differ in Essence From Human Art

Pope Leo XIV has said that artwork made by people and images produced by machines are different in kind, not just in appearance. In a Friday post on X, he said the Church wants to strengthen its partnership with artists and cultural institutions in order to "safeguard our humanity."

What the pope said

Leo described the gap as ontological, a word that concerns what a thing fundamentally is. In his view, a human painting and an AI picture could look alike and still be different at their core. He argued that a machine only calculates statistics across millions of images made by other people, and that algorithms have no spark of humanity.

Image generators are indeed trained on huge collections of existing pictures. They learn patterns and use them to produce new images, without the hands or life experience of a human creator.

Context: AI slop and the pope's earlier steps

  • He did not use the phrase "AI slop," but his remarks touch the same debate. Merriam-Webster picked the term, meaning low-quality mass-produced AI content, as its 2025 word of the year.
  • In May he published his first encyclical, Magnifica Humanitas, which holds that technology is never neutral and that data should be seen as a common good.
  • The same month, the Vatican created an AI commission drawing on seven Vatican bodies to coordinate internal approaches.
  • On September 25, at the Élysée Palace in Paris, he told French authorities that science and technology without conscience can pull people off an ethical path.

Authorship disputes

In April, an AI-detection extension from Pangram Labs flagged several posts on the pope's X account as probably AI-written. The Vatican did not answer requests for comment then. Detectors are unreliable: in 2024 ZeroGPT rated the U.S. Declaration of Independence as 97.93% AI-generated. In July, the firm Proudly Human reported that a set of Leo's speeches and writings on education and AI was human-authored.

Authorship also matters legally. In March, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear Thaler v. Perlmutter, which leaves standing a ruling that copyright requires a human author for art made wholly by AI. Meanwhile, Cara, a portfolio network built to exclude AI images, had nearly 900,000 users by June 2024.

Why it matters

Crypto and AI often overlap in areas like digital art, NFTs and online content. This story shows that questions of who made a work, and whether it counts as original, are moving into religion, courts and artist communities. For a newcomer, it is a reminder that ownership and authorship claims for digital creations can depend on human involvement, and that tools for verifying it are still imperfect.

Originally reported by Decrypt.