Federal Judge Clears Peraire-Bueno Brothers of Fraud in Ethereum MEV Case

A federal judge in the United States has entered acquittals for Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, brothers who were tried over an alleged $25 million exploit involving Ethereum trading bots. Judge Jessica Clarke decided that the government had not proven the kind of material misrepresentation that wire fraud requires. Her ruling followed a mistrial in November 2025, when jurors could not agree on a verdict.

What prosecutors alleged and what the court decided

Prosecutors said the two men, both educated at MIT, took advantage of a weakness in MEV-Boost software in April 2023. In their account, the brothers baited sandwich-trading bots into particular transactions and then interfered with them, pulling out roughly $25 million within about 12 seconds.

Judge Clarke concluded that the transactions did not rest on false promises and so did not amount to criminal fraud. She stressed that she was not deciding whether the conduct was ethical, or whether it might violate some other law.

  • Defendants: Anton and James Peraire-Bueno
  • Amount at issue: $25 million
  • Alleged exploit: April 2023
  • First trial: ended in a mistrial in November 2025 with a deadlocked jury

Reaction and a similar precedent

Peter Van Valkenburgh, executive director of the advocacy group Coin Center, welcomed the outcome as "excellent news." He argued that the government's "honest validator" theory could allow prosecutors to use wire fraud law to define proper behavior for Ethereum validators. In his view, anyone participating in an open network might worry that their actions could later be called dishonest.

The judge also cited a 2025 ruling in the case of Avraham Eisenberg, the Mango Markets trader, where a judge found too little evidence of false representations.

Why it matters

MEV, or maximal extractable value, is extra profit available to those who can influence how transactions are ordered or included in a block. Sandwich trading is one MEV strategy: a bot places trades before and after another user's trade to profit from the resulting price movement. This case asked whether exploiting the way that system works can count as fraud.

For anyone new to crypto, the lesson is in the legal reasoning. The court looked for a false statement or promise rather than asking whether the behavior seemed unfair. Blockchain networks run on rules enforced by software, and courts are still figuring out how older statutes like wire fraud apply to them. The decision is narrow: it does not endorse what the brothers did, only finds that prosecutors failed to prove this specific fraud theory.

Originally reported by Cointelegraph.