A working paper from the Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland reports that differing beliefs about future returns do more to explain who owns cryptocurrency than demographics do. The authors are Michael Weber, Bernardo Candia, Olivier Coibion and Yuriy Gorodnichenko. They also ran an experiment in which showing people Bitcoin's recent performance raised both their desired crypto holdings and their later purchases.
What the survey found
The paper, titled "Do You Even Crypto, Bro? Cryptocurrencies in Household Finance," draws on repeated surveys of as many as 25,000 US households per wave.
- In the 2021 survey, 87% of non-owners and 54% of owners said they did not know what return to expect over the next year.
- Among those who did offer a forecast, owners expected an average 22% return, versus 7% for non-owners.
- Owners also tended to see crypto as less risky than non-owners did.
- A one-percentage-point rise in expected return was linked to a 0.8-point rise in the probability of owning crypto.
Expectations about returns and risk together explained more of the variation in ownership than age, income and gender. For stocks, bonds and gold, the researchers say, demographic and financial traits usually explain more than expectations do.
Demographics still play a part. People under 40 were 13 percentage points more likely to own crypto than those over 60. Men were about 4 points more likely than women, and higher-income and wealthier households were also more likely to own it.
The information experiment
In 2025, households were randomly assigned information about Bitcoin, stocks, GameStop or inflation. Those shown Bitcoin's previous 12-month return raised their desired crypto allocation by roughly 2 percentage points. That is about 47% above the 4.3% allocation in the control group. Their actual later purchases rose by about 2.5 percentage points.
The effect was concentrated among people who said they did not own crypto because they lacked information. People who already thought crypto was a bad investment mostly did not respond.
The paper also looked at spending. When Bitcoin's price doubled, a household with its whole financial portfolio in crypto was 1.4 percentage points more likely to buy a durable good, about a 7% increase. The effect did not carry over into ordinary spending. The authors compare crypto gains to gambling income or lottery winnings rather than lasting wealth.
Why it matters
For anyone learning about crypto, the paper shows that ownership is shaped heavily by belief and by what information people see. The authors suggest a possible feedback loop: past gains attract new buyers, whose purchases can push prices higher and draw in more buyers. They also argue that the lack of shared information and beliefs among investors helps explain crypto's price volatility. In their words, volatility will likely remain a defining feature "for the foreseeable future." It is a reminder to look beyond recent returns when judging an asset.




