Better Markets, a nonprofit financial reform group, has criticized a CFTC proposal to oversee certain retail crypto transactions. The group argues that the Commodity Futures Trading Commission is the wrong regulator for the job and that ordinary investors would get weaker protection than under the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).
What the CFTC proposed
On Monday, the CFTC asked the public for comment on a possible framework covering margined, leveraged or financed retail crypto transactions, using authority it already has. The framework also considers a federal category for crypto trading platforms, which would put qualifying exchanges directly under CFTC oversight.
The objections
Benjamin Schiffrin, director of securities policy at Better Markets, made several points:
- The CFTC has no specific investor protection mandate, unlike the SEC.
- The agency has historically supervised commodity and derivatives markets, which are dominated by large institutions rather than retail participants.
- CFTC rules do not give customers the same protections as securities rules enforced by the SEC.
- The statutory authority the CFTC cites was originally aimed at fraud in leveraged precious-metals trading, not at making the agency the main retail crypto regulator.
- The framework could allow affiliations between market participants, which Better Markets believes contributed to the collapse of FTX.
Schiffrin also questioned CFTC Chair Mike Selig's stated goal of making the United States the global center for crypto activity, and said crypto "still lacks any real-world use case."
Regulators act as legislation stalls
The dispute comes after the CLARITY Act stalled in Congress. Both the CFTC and the SEC have signaled they are willing to move ahead under existing law. The SEC has advanced proposals to ease custody rules for investment advisers, allowed limited trading of tokenized US stocks, and issued new guidance on how securities laws apply to crypto assets.
Nate Geraci, president of NovaDius Wealth Management, offered a different view. He said the industry wants clear rules, and that if Congress cannot supply them, the CFTC and SEC may need to step in.
Why it matters
In the United States, which agency oversees a crypto product determines what protections buyers receive. Securities rules typically include investor-focused requirements, while commodity and derivatives rules were built mainly for institutional markets. With Congress yet to pass comprehensive crypto legislation, agencies are shaping the rules themselves, and advocacy groups, industry figures and regulators disagree about who should lead. For anyone learning about crypto, this explains why the rules around leveraged and retail trading can differ by platform and remain unsettled.




